secondary_synthesis · src_maeir_hitchcock_horwitz_2013_philistine_identity
On the Constitution and Transformation of Philistine Identity
Aren M. Maeir, Louise A. Hitchcock, Liora Kolska Horwitz · 2013
Citation metadata
- Type
- journal article
- Publication
- Oxford Journal of Archaeology, vol. 32, no. 1, 1-38
- Peer reviewed
- Yes
Records informed by this source
- myth interpretation Samson cycle as Philistine-Israelite borderland heroic traditionEvidence confidence: lowinforms · contextualizes · Philistine border and identity dynamics
Provides historical social setting.
- property Archaeological proxy, not ethnicityEvidence confidence: highinforms · defines · identity theory and Philistine evidence
Supports multi-proxy identity analysis.
- entity PhilistiaEvidence confidence: highinforms · defines · regional identity formation
Supports dynamic use.
- date assertion Philistia — date assertioninforms · defines · regional identity formation
Supports dynamic use.
- property assignment Philistine communities — has property — Archaeological proxy, not ethnicityEvidence confidence: very highinforms · defines · multi-proxy identity model
Supports assignment.
- claim Philistine-associated pottery distributions do not measure the number or exact ancestry of migrants.Evidence confidence: near certaininforms · defines · multi-proxy identity model
Provides method.
- event Local integration and transformation of Philistine communitiesEvidence confidence: highinforms · proposes interpretation · identity transformation model
Primary interpretive synthesis.
- claim The end of Egyptian control altered opportunities and constraints but cannot be treated as the sole cause of highland settlement, Philistine formation, or every city destruction.Evidence confidence: highinforms · proposes interpretation · mixed formation processes
Shows distinct coastal mechanisms.
- claim The conventional connection between Egyptian Peleset and later Philistines is plausible, but it does not prove that every Philistine community descended from one homogeneous Pel…Evidence confidence: highinforms · proposes interpretation · identity transformation
Shows later heterogeneity.
- entity Philistine communitiesEvidence confidence: highinforms · proposes interpretation · pp. 1-38
Models changing identity.
- causal hypothesis Limited migration plus rapid local integration model for Philistine formationEvidence confidence: highinforms · proposes interpretation · identity transformation
Social model.
- causal hypothesis Southern Levant systems-transformation modelEvidence confidence: highinforms · proposes interpretation · identity transformation
Migration/integration mechanism.
- ranked model Philistine origins and integrationEvidence confidence: highinforms · proposes interpretation · identity model
Transformation.
- relationship Canaanite city communities — contributes to formation of — Philistine communitiesEvidence confidence: highinforms · proposes interpretation · identity transformation
Supports relationship.
- date assertion Local integration and transformation of Philistine communities — date assertionEvidence confidence: highinforms · proposes interpretation · identity transformation model
Primary interpretive synthesis.
- date assertion Philistine communities — date assertioninforms · proposes interpretation · pp. 1-38
Models changing identity.
- relationship Peleset — plausibly related to — Philistine communitiesEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · provides source criticism · identity transformation
Limits equation.
- claim Philistia should not be mapped as a fixed Late Bronze Age territory before Philistine-associated Iron Age settlement and political evidence appears.Evidence confidence: very highinforms · supports distribution · identity and regional distribution
Constrains the label to changing Iron Age contexts.
- relationship Research record — associated withEvidence confidence: lowsupports · contextualizes · Philistine border and identity dynamics
Provides historical social setting.