secondary · src_manassa_2003
The Great Karnak Inscription of Merneptah: Grand Strategy in the 13th Century BC
Colleen Manassa · 2003
Citation metadata
- Type
- academic monograph / primary-text edition
- Publication
- Yale Egyptological Seminar
- Peer reviewed
- Yes
Records informed by this source
- date assertion Tehenu — date assertioninforms · contextualizes · Introduction and commentary on western names in Merneptah’s record
Provides philological and historical context for western labels.
- entity TehenuEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · Introduction and commentary on western names in Merneptah’s record
Provides philological and historical context for western labels.
- claim Merneptah’s Great Karnak Inscription records a Libyan-led coalition including several groups later placed under the modern Sea Peoples umbrella.Evidence confidence: highinforms · establishes
Supports the claim: Merneptah’s Great Karnak Inscription records a Libyan-led coalition including several groups later placed under the modern Sea Peoples umbrella.
- relationship Merey son of Dedy — leader of — LibuEvidence confidence: very highinforms · provides primary evidence · Great Karnak Inscription, Year 5 narrative
Directly attests the leadership relationship.
- date assertion Libu — date assertioninforms · provides primary evidence · Great Karnak Inscription, Year 5 campaign text and commentary
Attests the Libyan-led coalition and the ruler Merey.
- entity LibuEvidence confidence: highinforms · provides primary evidence · Great Karnak Inscription, Year 5 campaign text and commentary
Attests the Libyan-led coalition and the ruler Merey.
- date assertion Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led Coalition — date assertionEvidence confidence: highinforms · provides primary evidence · Great Karnak Inscription, Year 5
- event Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led CoalitionEvidence confidence: highinforms · provides primary evidence · Great Karnak Inscription, Year 5
Source relationship recorded for Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led Coalition.
- date assertion Merey son of Dedy — date assertioninforms · provides primary evidence · Great Karnak Inscription, Year 5 narrative and translation
Provides the name, patronymic, and leadership role.
- entity Merey son of DedyEvidence confidence: very highinforms · provides primary evidence · Great Karnak Inscription, Year 5 narrative and translation
Provides the name, patronymic, and leadership role.
- relationship Libu — participated in — Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led CoalitionEvidence confidence: very highinforms · provides primary evidence · Great Karnak Inscription, Year 5 narrative
Direct primary-text attestation.
- relationship Research record — associated withEvidence confidence: very highinforms · provides primary text edition · Great Karnak Inscription, translation and commentary
Directly supports the inscription and source criticism.
- relationship Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led Coalition — involved or associated with — Production of Merneptah's Great Karnak victory inscriptionEvidence confidence: very highsupports · provides primary text edition · Great Karnak Inscription, translation and commentary
Directly supports the inscription and source criticism.
- event Production of Merneptah's Great Karnak victory inscriptionEvidence confidence: very highsupports · provides primary text edition · Great Karnak Inscription, translation and commentary
Directly supports the inscription and source criticism.
- relationship Production of Merneptah's Great Karnak victory inscription — occurred at or involved — KarnakEvidence confidence: very highsupports · provides primary text edition · Great Karnak Inscription, translation and commentary
Directly supports the inscription and source criticism.
- date assertion Production of Merneptah's Great Karnak victory inscription — date assertionEvidence confidence: very highsupports · provides primary text edition · Great Karnak Inscription, translation and commentary
Directly supports the inscription and source criticism.
- relationship Merneptah — involved or associated with — Production of Merneptah's Great Karnak victory inscriptionEvidence confidence: very highsupports · provides primary text edition · Great Karnak Inscription, translation and commentary
Directly supports the inscription and source criticism.
- date assertion Merneptah — date assertionEvidence confidence: highsupports · provides regnal attestation · Ruler chronology and attested Year 10
Supports the regnal-year minimum and chronology caution.
- claim Egyptian records of Libyan wars establish military coalitions and captured or settled people, but do not by themselves prove migration by entire peoples.Evidence confidence: highsupports · supports · Great Karnak Inscription and genre discussion
Supports the coalition while exposing the source’s rhetorical form.
- claim Libu, Meshwesh, Tjemehu, and Tehenu should be represented as source-dependent ancient labels, not as fixed ethnic territories.Evidence confidence: highsupports · supports · Great Karnak Inscription edition and commentary
Shows one context-specific list and coalition.
- claim Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led Coalition is best dated in this release to approximately 1208 BCE.Evidence confidence: highsupports · supports
Supports the claim: Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led Coalition is best dated in this release to approximately 1208 BCE.
- claim Sea Peoples is a modern umbrella for source-specific named groups and does not establish one ethnicity, homeland, polity, or coordinated migration.Evidence confidence: very highsupports · supports
Supports the claim: ‘Sea Peoples’ is a modern scholarly umbrella for several differently attested names and should not be represented as a demonstrated single ethnicity, state, nation or unified population.
- property assignment Shekelesh — source describes as — Group Named in Egyptian RecordsEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports assignment
The name Shekelesh is attested in Egyptian textual evidence, though transliteration and identification questions remain.
- property assignment Ekwesh — modern scholars classify as — Sea PeoplesEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports assignment
Ekwesh is conventionally included in modern Sea Peoples discussions because the name occurs in relevant Egyptian conflict records.
- property assignment Ekwesh — source describes as — Group Named in Egyptian RecordsEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports assignment
The name Ekwesh is attested in Egyptian textual evidence, though transliteration and identification questions remain.
- property assignment Teresh — modern scholars classify as — Sea PeoplesEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports assignment
Teresh is conventionally included in modern Sea Peoples discussions because the name occurs in relevant Egyptian conflict records.
- property assignment Teresh — source describes as — Group Named in Egyptian RecordsEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports assignment
The name Teresh is attested in Egyptian textual evidence, though transliteration and identification questions remain.
- property assignment Lukka — modern scholars classify as — Sea PeoplesEvidence confidence: moderatesupports · supports assignment
Lukka is conventionally included in modern Sea Peoples discussions because the name occurs in relevant Egyptian conflict records.
- property assignment Lukka — source describes as — Group Named in Egyptian RecordsEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports assignment
The name Lukka is attested in Egyptian textual evidence, though transliteration and identification questions remain.
- property assignment Shekelesh — modern scholars classify as — Sea PeoplesEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports assignment
Shekelesh is conventionally included in modern Sea Peoples discussions because the name occurs in relevant Egyptian conflict records.
- property assignment Sherden — source describes as — Group Named in Egyptian RecordsEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports assignment
The name Sherden is attested in Egyptian textual evidence, though transliteration and identification questions remain.
- property assignment Sherden — modern scholars classify as — Sea PeoplesEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports assignment
Sherden is conventionally included in modern Sea Peoples discussions because the name occurs in relevant Egyptian conflict records.
- property assignment Great Karnak Inscription of Merneptah — has property — Primary Textual EvidenceEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports assignment
The inscription is a primary Egyptian record for Merneptah's Year 5 campaign and named groups.
- property assignment New Kingdom Egypt — is a — New Kingdom EgyptEvidence confidence: very highsupports · supports assignment
The polity is the New Kingdom Egyptian state itself.
- entity LukkaEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports entity record
Supports the existence, description, classification, or historical context of Lukka.
- entity EgyptEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports entity record
Supports the existence, description, classification, or historical context of Egypt.
- entity New Kingdom EgyptEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports entity record
Supports the existence, description, classification, or historical context of New Kingdom Egypt.
- entity SherdenEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports entity record
Supports the existence, description, classification, or historical context of Sherden.
- entity ShekeleshEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports entity record
Supports the existence, description, classification, or historical context of Shekelesh.
- entity EkweshEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports entity record
Supports the existence, description, classification, or historical context of Ekwesh.
- entity TereshEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports entity record
Supports the existence, description, classification, or historical context of Teresh.
- entity Great Karnak Inscription of MerneptahEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports entity record
Supports the existence, description, classification, or historical context of Great Karnak Inscription of Merneptah.
- causal hypothesis Unified Sea Peoples InvasionUnsupported explanationConfidence in this assessment, not in the proposed storysupports · supports model component
Supports one or more evidential components of Unified Sea Peoples Invasion.
- causal hypothesis Migration and Warfare-Dominated Collapsesupports · supports model component
Supports one or more evidential components of Migration and Warfare-Dominated Collapse.
- property New Kingdom Egyptsupports · supports property definition
Supports the definition or scholarly use of the property New Kingdom Egypt.
- property Sea Peoplessupports · supports property definition
Supports the definition or scholarly use of the property Sea Peoples.
- property Primary Textual Evidencesupports · supports property definition
Supports the definition or scholarly use of the property Primary Textual Evidence.
- property Group Named in Egyptian Recordssupports · supports property definition
Supports the definition or scholarly use of the property Group Named in Egyptian Records.
- relationship Great Karnak Inscription of Merneptah — participated in — Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led CoalitionEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports relationship
Great Karnak Inscription of Merneptah is a participant, evidential object, or directly involved entity in Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led Coalition.
- relationship Shekelesh — participated in — Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led CoalitionEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports relationship
Shekelesh is a participant, evidential object, or directly involved entity in Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led Coalition.
- relationship Sherden — participated in — Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led CoalitionEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports relationship
Sherden is a participant, evidential object, or directly involved entity in Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led Coalition.
- relationship Lukka — participated in — Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led CoalitionEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports relationship
Lukka is a participant, evidential object, or directly involved entity in Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led Coalition.
- relationship Great Karnak Inscription of Merneptah — names — SherdenEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports relationship
The Great Karnak Inscription names Sherden in the context of Merneptah's Year 5 conflict.
- relationship Ekwesh — participated in — Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led CoalitionEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports relationship
Ekwesh is a participant, evidential object, or directly involved entity in Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led Coalition.
- relationship New Kingdom Egypt — participated in — Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led CoalitionEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports relationship
New Kingdom Egypt is a participant, evidential object, or directly involved entity in Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led Coalition.
- relationship Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led Coalition — occurred in — EgyptEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports relationship
Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led Coalition is geographically assigned to Egypt.
- relationship Great Karnak Inscription of Merneptah — located in — EgyptEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports relationship
Great Karnak Inscription of Merneptah is located in or geographically associated with Egypt.
- relationship New Kingdom Egypt — located in — EgyptEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports relationship
New Kingdom Egypt is located in or geographically associated with Egypt.
- relationship Teresh — participated in — Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led CoalitionEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports relationship
Teresh is a participant, evidential object, or directly involved entity in Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led Coalition.
- relationship Great Karnak Inscription of Merneptah — names — ShekeleshEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports relationship
The Great Karnak Inscription names Shekelesh in the context of Merneptah's Year 5 conflict.
- relationship Great Karnak Inscription of Merneptah — records — Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led CoalitionEvidence confidence: very highsupports · supports relationship
Great Karnak Inscription of Merneptah is a primary textual source for Merneptah’s Year 5 Conflict with a Libyan-Led Coalition.
- relationship Great Karnak Inscription of Merneptah — names — LukkaEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports relationship
The Great Karnak Inscription names Lukka in the context of Merneptah's Year 5 conflict.
- relationship Great Karnak Inscription of Merneptah — names — TereshEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports relationship
The Great Karnak Inscription names Teresh in the context of Merneptah's Year 5 conflict.
- relationship Great Karnak Inscription of Merneptah — names — EkweshEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports relationship
The Great Karnak Inscription names Ekwesh in the context of Merneptah's Year 5 conflict.
- entity MerneptahEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports ruler and reign context · Ruler/period discussion
Supports inclusion, approximate reign and historical significance.
- date assertion Merneptah — date assertionEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports ruler and reign context · Ruler/period discussion
Supports inclusion, approximate reign and historical significance.
- relationship Merneptah — ruled or claimed kingship in — New Kingdom EgyptEvidence confidence: highsupports · supports ruler relationship · Ruler and period discussion
Supports kingship assignment and chronology.