secondary_synthesis · src_sergi_2023_two_houses
The Two Houses of Israel: State Formation and the Origins of Pan-Israelite Identity
Omer Sergi · 2023
Citation metadata
- Type
- academic monograph
- Publication
- SBL Press
- Peer reviewed
- Yes
Records informed by this source
- relationship Judahites — associated population of — Kingdom of JudahEvidence confidence: highinforms · contextualizes · Judah formation
Supports relationship.
- date assertion Omride consolidation of the kingdom of Israel — date assertionEvidence confidence: highinforms · contextualizes · Omride and pan-Israelite chapters
Provides political synthesis.
- event Omride consolidation of the kingdom of IsraelEvidence confidence: highinforms · contextualizes · Omride and pan-Israelite chapters
Provides political synthesis.
- claim Judahite, Judean, and Jew are related but chronologically and semantically distinct terms.Evidence confidence: very highinforms · contextualizes · Judahite formation
Provides early political context.
- date assertion Judahites — date assertioninforms · contextualizes · Judah formation and identity chapters
Treats Judahite formation separately from Israelite and later Jewish identity.
- date assertion Kingdom of Israel — date assertioninforms · contextualizes · state-formation chapters
Provides a modern reconstruction of formation and identity.
- entity Kingdom of IsraelEvidence confidence: highinforms · contextualizes · state-formation chapters
Provides a modern reconstruction of formation and identity.
- entity JudahitesEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · Judah formation and identity chapters
Treats Judahite formation separately from Israelite and later Jewish identity.
- relationship United Monarchy tradition — later historiography about — Kingdom of JudahEvidence confidence: highinforms · critiques interpretation · pan-Israelite identity
Supports relation.
- entity United Monarchy traditionEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · critiques interpretation · pan-Israelite identity and state-formation analysis
Provides an alternative asymmetric model.
- event Formation and redaction of United Monarchy traditionsEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · critiques interpretation · pan-Israelite identity model
Provides later ideological context.
- date assertion Formation and redaction of United Monarchy traditions — date assertionEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · critiques interpretation · pan-Israelite identity model
Provides later ideological context.
- date assertion Judah — date assertioninforms · defines · Judah state-formation chapters
Separates Judah from pan-Israelite identity.
- entity JudahEvidence confidence: highinforms · defines · Judah state-formation chapters
Separates Judah from pan-Israelite identity.
- date assertion Early consolidation of the northern Israelite polity — date assertionEvidence confidence: highinforms · proposes interpretation · Omride formation
Provides synthesis.
- claim Israelite and Judahite identities formed through multistage processes involving local continuity, political consolidation, regional differentiation, and later pan-Israelite trad…Disputed interpretationConfidence in this assessment: moderateConfidence in the stated assessmentinforms · proposes interpretation · state formation and pan-Israelite identity
Provides integrated model.
- claim The United Monarchy debate is not a binary choice between a vast empire exactly as narrated and no historical Davidic or Jerusalem-centred polity.Evidence confidence: highinforms · proposes interpretation · asymmetric state model
Provides intermediate alternative.
- claim The biblical division of one United Monarchy should not be assumed as the only model for the emergence of Israel and Judah.Evidence confidence: moderateinforms · proposes interpretation · two-house state formation
Provides alternative model.
- myth interpretation United Monarchy as remembered golden age and pan-Israelite political idealEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · proposes interpretation · pan-Israelite identity development
Supports later unity construction.
- claim Israel is a historically changing term that cannot be assigned one unchanged population, territory, or polity from the Merneptah Stele through the monarchic period.Evidence confidence: highinforms · proposes interpretation · pan-Israelite identity development
Separates polity and later identity.
- entity Kingdom of JudahEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · proposes interpretation · Judah state-formation chapters
Provides a recent asymmetric state-formation model.
- date assertion Kingdom of Judah — date assertioninforms · proposes interpretation · Judah state-formation chapters
Provides a recent asymmetric state-formation model.
- entity Division of Israel and Judah traditionsEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · proposes interpretation · state formation and pan-Israelite identity
Provides a historically asymmetric alternative to a simple split of one large state.
- date assertion Division of Israel and Judah traditions — date assertioninforms · proposes interpretation · state formation and pan-Israelite identity
Provides a historically asymmetric alternative to a simple split of one large state.
- event Early consolidation of the northern Israelite polityEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · proposes interpretation · northern state-formation chapters
Provides recent synthesis.
- event Gradual development of the Judahite highland polityEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · proposes interpretation · Judah formation chapters
Supports asymmetric development.
- property assignment Kingdom of Israel — has property — Polity extent uncertainEvidence confidence: very highinforms · proposes interpretation · state formation
Supports assignment.
- causal hypothesis Asymmetric formation of Israel and JudahEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · proposes interpretation · two-house model
Principal synthesis.
- ranked model United Monarchy scale and chronologyEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · proposes interpretation · later pan-Israelite model
Preferred framing.
- relationship Kingdom of Israel — historically related but distinct — Kingdom of JudahEvidence confidence: highinforms · proposes interpretation · two-house model
Supports relationship.
- date assertion Early consolidation of the northern Israelite polity — date assertionEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · proposes interpretation · northern state-formation chapters
Provides recent synthesis.
- date assertion Gradual development of the Judahite highland polity — date assertionEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · proposes interpretation · Judah formation chapters
Supports asymmetric development.
- date assertion Gradual development of the Judahite highland polity — date assertionEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · proposes interpretation · Judah formation chapters
Supports asymmetric later growth.
- relationship Research record — associated withEvidence confidence: moderatesupports · proposes interpretation · pan-Israelite identity development
Supports later unity construction.