secondary · src_srsc1_zimansky_2012_urartians
Urartian and the Urartians
Paul E. Zimansky · 2012
Citation metadata
- Type
- handbook chapter
- Publication
- Oxford University Press, 548–559
- Peer reviewed
- Yes
Records informed by this source
- claim Genetic ancestry cannot by itself establish whether a Late Bronze or Early Iron Age community spoke Armenian, Kartvelian, Hurrian, Urartian, Iranian, or another language.Evidence confidence: near certaincontextualizes · contextualizes · State, population, and identity distinctions
Source linked to claim record claim_srsc1_adna_not_language.
- relationship Uruatri — possible historical predecessor label — UrartuEvidence confidence: moderatecontextualizes · contextualizes · Urartian identity and state
Source linked to relationship record rel_srsc1_uruatri_precedes_urartu.
- date assertion Emergence of the Urartian state — date assertionEvidence confidence: very highcontradicts_or_criticizes · critiques identity equation · pp. 548–559
Distinguishes state, language, and populations.
- event Emergence of the Urartian stateEvidence confidence: very highcontradicts_or_criticizes · critiques identity equation · pp. 548–559
Distinguishes state, language, and populations.
- date assertion Emergence of the Urartian state — date assertionEvidence confidence: moderatecontradicts_or_criticizes · critiques identity equation · pp. 548–559
Distinguishes state, language, and populations.
- relationship Research record — associated withEvidence confidence: very highinforms · critiques identity equation · pp. 548–559
Distinguishes state, language, and populations.
- relationship Research record — associated withEvidence confidence: very highinforms · critiques identity equation · pp. 548–559
Distinguishes state, language, and populations.
- relationship Research record — associated withEvidence confidence: very highinforms · critiques identity equation · pp. 548–559
Distinguishes state, language, and populations.
- relationship Research record — associated withEvidence confidence: very highinforms · critiques identity equation · pp. 548–559
Distinguishes state, language, and populations.
- date assertion Uruatri — date assertioninforms · provides or interprets textual attestation · Relevant inscription, historical synthesis, or source criticism
- date assertion Diauehi — date assertioninforms · provides or interprets textual attestation · Relevant inscription, historical synthesis, or source criticism
- date assertion Urartu — date assertioninforms · provides or interprets textual attestation · Relevant inscription, historical synthesis, or source criticism
- claim Modern nationalist narratives can overstate continuity between archaeological cultures and present nations, so identity claims require explicit source criticism.Evidence confidence: near certainsupports · provides case · Urartian identity distinctions
Source linked to claim record claim_srsc1_nationalist_legacy_requires_source_criticism.
- entity UrartuEvidence confidence: very highsupports · provides or interprets textual attestation · Relevant inscription, historical synthesis, or source criticism
Source linked to entity record pol_srsc1_urartu.
- entity DiauehiEvidence confidence: highsupports · provides or interprets textual attestation · Relevant inscription, historical synthesis, or source criticism
Source linked to entity record text_srsc1_diauehi.
- entity UruatriEvidence confidence: moderatesupports · provides or interprets textual attestation · Relevant inscription, historical synthesis, or source criticism
Source linked to entity record text_srsc1_uruatri.
- claim Urartian state material culture is an administrative and political assemblage, not a direct measure of homogeneous ethnicity.Evidence confidence: highsupports · supports · Urartian/Urartians distinction
Source linked to claim record claim_srsc1_urartian_assemblage_not_ethnicity.
- claim Early Assyrian Uruatri should not be represented as the already consolidated ninth-century Urartian state.Evidence confidence: highsupports · supports · State and population distinctions
Source linked to claim record claim_srsc1_uruatri_not_mature_urartu.