secondary_review · src_thomas_2016_united_monarchy
The United Monarchy: State of the Question
Zachary Thomas · 2016
Citation metadata
- Type
- journal review article
- Publication
- Biblical Theology Bulletin, vol. 46, no. 2, 85-99
- Peer reviewed
- Yes
Records informed by this source
- myth interpretation United Monarchy as remembered golden age and pan-Israelite political idealEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · state of question
Preserves historical alternatives.
- date assertion Kingdom of Judah — date assertioninforms · contextualizes · state of the question
Summarizes competing chronologies and scale models.
- entity United Monarchy traditionEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · entire review
Summarizes archaeological and historical positions.
- entity David traditionsEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · David and monarchy debate
Separates later dynasty evidence from narrative scale.
- date assertion David traditions — date assertioninforms · contextualizes · David and monarchy debate
Separates later dynasty evidence from narrative scale.
- entity Solomon traditionsEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · Solomon and tenth-century evidence review
Summarizes competing scale and chronology models.
- date assertion Solomon traditions — date assertioninforms · contextualizes · Solomon and tenth-century evidence review
Summarizes competing scale and chronology models.
- event Gradual development of the Judahite highland polityEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · state-of-question review
Documents model range.
- event Early Iron Age development of JerusalemEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · state of the question
Summarizes the debate.
- event Formation and redaction of United Monarchy traditionsEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · state of question
Provides model range.
- property assignment United Monarchy tradition — has property — Literary tradition, not contemporary event reportEvidence confidence: near certaininforms · contextualizes · evidence review
Supports assignment.
- property assignment Kingdom of Judah — has property — Polity extent uncertainEvidence confidence: very highinforms · contextualizes · scale debate
Supports assignment.
- causal hypothesis Asymmetric formation of Israel and JudahEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · competing models
Counterpositions.
- claim Attribution of monumental gates, palaces, and administrative systems to Solomon depends on contested ceramic and radiocarbon chronologies.Evidence confidence: highinforms · contextualizes · chronology debate
Summarizes alternatives.
- claim Absence of one expected artifact or text is not, by itself, sufficient proof that a complex biblical tradition is wholly true or wholly false.Evidence confidence: near certaininforms · contextualizes · evidential debate
Shows multidimensional testing.
- entity Kingdom of JudahEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · state of the question
Summarizes competing chronologies and scale models.
- ranked model United Monarchy scale and chronologyEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · state of question
Model range.
- ranked model Tenth-century JerusalemEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · review
Balanced framing.
- relationship United Monarchy tradition — later historiography about — Kingdom of IsraelEvidence confidence: highinforms · contextualizes · debate review
Supports relation.
- date assertion Gradual development of the Judahite highland polity — date assertionEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · state-of-question review
Documents model range.
- date assertion Early Iron Age development of Jerusalem — date assertionEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · state of the question
Summarizes the debate.
- date assertion Formation and redaction of United Monarchy traditions — date assertionEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · state of question
Provides model range.
- date assertion United Monarchy tradition — date assertionEvidence confidence: moderateinforms · contextualizes · chronology and model review
Provides the range.
- date assertion Gradual development of the Judahite highland polity — date assertionEvidence confidence: lowinforms · contextualizes · maximal/intermediate models
Provides debate context.
- claim The United Monarchy debate is not a binary choice between a vast empire exactly as narrated and no historical Davidic or Jerusalem-centred polity.Evidence confidence: highinforms · contextualizes · state of question
Shows multidimensional debate.
- claim No securely identified contemporary inscription from Solomon's putative reign directly names Solomon.Evidence confidence: highinforms · contextualizes · evidence review
Documents the evidential structure.
- claim Jerusalem was occupied in the tenth century BCE, but its population, monumental scale, administrative capacity, and control over distant regions remain contested.Evidence confidence: highinforms · contextualizes · debate review
Shows range.
- claim Evidence for David combines later biblical traditions and a probable ninth-century dynastic reference rather than a contemporary royal archive.Evidence confidence: highinforms · contextualizes · David evidence review
Separates evidence types.
- myth interpretation David and Goliath as heroic borderland memoryEvidence confidence: lowinforms · provides source criticism · Davidic tradition and evidence
Constrains historicity.
- relationship Research record — associated withEvidence confidence: moderatesupports · contextualizes · state of question
Preserves historical alternatives.
- relationship Research record — associated withEvidence confidence: lowsupports · provides source criticism · Davidic tradition and evidence
Constrains historicity.